An investigation by BBC Eye has uncovered that Moch Subchi Azal Tsani, an Indonesian teacher convicted of sexually abusing a student, was released from prison earlier than expected. Known as Bechi, he is the son of a prominent Islamic religious leader. His trial was highly publicized in Indonesia, where Islamic boarding schools are a common choice for education among Muslim families. Bechi was apprehended in 2022, following a tense standoff at his father’s school in East Java, which involved nearly 1,000 riot police due to resistance from his supporters.
Controversial Trial and Sentence
Initially sentenced to seven years for sexual assault, Bechi’s case stirred national debate. Despite prosecutors pushing for a 16-year maximum sentence for rape, the court only found him guilty of the lesser charge. The school’s operating license was revoked by the government, but President Joko Widodo intervened to keep it open, citing the involvement of an individual rather than the institution.
New allegations have since surfaced, suggesting the school and Bechi’s family attempted to suppress further accusations. The National Commission on Violence against Women has highlighted a growing crisis of sexual violence within Islamic boarding schools, attributing it to the influence of religious leaders who hinder accountability and discourage victims from speaking out.
Undercover Revelations and Victim Testimonies
Despite being eligible for parole in 2027, Bechi was released in August 2025 due to “sentence remissions,” as confirmed by Indonesia’s Ministry of Immigration and Corrections. However, the ministry did not clarify the reasons behind the sentence reduction. Undercover footage now shows Bechi attending public events, much to the dismay of his victims who were not informed of his release.
One victim, Ira Puspitasari, waived her right to anonymity to share her ordeal, revealing years of abuse starting when she was just 15. Despite initially reporting the abuse, she was intimidated into retracting her claims. Ira expressed disbelief at seeing Bechi in public, feeling as though justice had failed her.
Community Impact and Political Connections
The case has drawn significant attention due to Bechi’s father’s political influence. Kiai Muchtar Mu’thi is known for blending Islamic teachings with nationalism, attracting numerous followers to his East Java school. The institution has been a hub for political figures, including visits from former presidential candidates.
The family’s connections have played a role in the reluctance of victims to pursue legal action. Ira, for instance, withdrew her allegations after receiving threats from Bechi’s supporters. Her experience highlights the broader issue of power dynamics and intimidation in such cases, underscoring the need for stronger protections for victims.
